Monday, October 20, 2025

Greg Sheridan, How Christians Can Succeed Today.

 


- This has to be the most theologically illiterate tome I’ve ever read. It fails on so many levels. 

- Sheridan has minimal understanding of the Judeo-Christian tradition and its richness. His book is simplistic in its Christian beliefs about the resurrection of Jesus, his ascension to heaven, and other ‘facts’. He makes no attempt to engage with the gospels and their stories and parables and whether the facts as presented actually happened, rather than being a rich collection of fictional and mythological elements that constructed the Old and New Testaments over centuries. 


- His constant quoting of familiar conservative writers of the last century like G.K.Chesterton, C.S.Lewis, and Malcolm Muggeridge, add absolutely nothing to his treatise other than supporting his simplicity. 


- His fundamental proposition is ‘with God out of the picture, humanity is immensely reduced’. Sheridan hates our modern world of secularism and modernism, initiated by science. ‘…our civilisation faces a choice between a re-enchanted culture informed by Christianity, or a future of chaos and cruelty’. The smartphone and social media are satanic. Popular culture is always anti-Christian. 


- There’s no analysis of the Catholic and Protestant traditions. ‘Christianity’ seems all one and the same. It becomes clear as the book proceeds he favours a fundamentalist evangelical extremism as his expression of true Christianity. 


- All that said, there are some positive features to the book. His chapter on St Paul, while being disappointing theologically, is excellent biographically and sociologically. 


- There’s also an excellent chapter on early Corinth and its deplorable practices regarding marriage, infanticide, forced abortions, and forced prostitution, and Christianity’s condemnation of these behaviours which inspired a revolutionary change for women. Paul preached the centrality of love. As a result the majority of early Christians were women. Sheridan makes clear how revolutionary Christian belief was at the time. 


- ’Christians exploded the sexual hierarchy of the ancient world as well as the social hierarchy.’ He’s also good on slavery, money, children, and death. ’Christians hold the most elevated view of the human body that has ever been imagined in human history’. 


- His chapter on the early church fathers is informed and enlightening. Clement, Ignatius, and Polycarp were all executed for their belief in Christ. Irenaeus was the first great theologian. Also influential were Gregory of Nyssa in Turkey, Tertullian of Carthage, Origen of Alexandria, and St Anthony the Great. The early centuries were prone to heresies from influential sources, which had to be met effectively.


- The most important figure was Augustine of Hippo in Algeria. His two important books were City of God and Confessions. 


- Part 2 of the book is biographical. Sheridan introduces us to ‘Contemporary Early Christians’, as he calls them. They’re presented as models of Christian behaviour for our time. Most of them are unknown. Some of them are celebrated for their conservative social and political positions - Jordan Peterson, Mike Pence, Niall Ferguson for example. He interviews them in a very journalistic, Sunday Magazine, style. He certainly doesn’t indulge in any critique of their views. 


- An exception would be Marilynne Robinson, a Christian novelist. She’s excellent on Genesis and other parts of the Old Testament. 


- It becomes quite clear at the end that Sheridan is positing a Christian rebellion against the modern world, a world of digital ‘gadgets’ like desktop computers, iPads, and mobile phones. These internet obsessions are destroying our society, making it ‘woke’ and meaningless, particularly for the young. He's a great fan of the recent 

movement in the US, and increasingly in Australia, called Classical Liberal Education. The curriculum of these private schools is centred around the great books of history, and ancient Greek civilisation. Many teach Latin as well. God is always central. 'In a distressed and bleeding culture, these classical schools are field hospitals; perhaps more than that  - base camps; perhaps more than that - signs of a new creation.' 


- Two stars out of five. Max. 




No comments:

Post a Comment